True InspiringStories

Cheyenne, WY

Taco Tuesday Was a Wyoming Trademark Until Jim Creel Decided Not to Feed the Lawyers

3 min readTaco John's International

A 1960s roadside taco stand in Cheyenne glows at sunset with period cars and customers nearby.

Before “Taco Tuesday” became a hashtag and an excuse to leave the pans in the cabinet, it was two cheerful words with paperwork behind them. Picture a Tuesday night with warm tortillas, crinkly wrappers, and the hope that dinner might cost less because the calendar said so. Jim Creel was the chief executive of Taco John’s, the Wyoming-born chain that had long called itself the home of Taco Tuesday. He was looking at a fight nobody could eat: a trademark battle over a phrase millions of people already used with salsa on their shirts and plans to “just grab tacos” after work. The choice was simple, but not small: defend the words in court, or let them go. The story began with John Turner’s small Taco House stand in Cheyenne in 1968. A year later, Harold W. Holmes and James Woodson bought the franchise rights and built it into Taco John’s. Somewhere along the way, “Taco Tuesday” became part of the chain’s identity. By 1989, Taco John’s had secured the federal trademark for “Taco Tuesday” in 49 states. New Jersey was the exception, where Gregory’s Restaurant & Bar held separate rights. It was one of those odd legal wrinkles that makes sense to lawyers and makes everyone else blink twice over their guacamole. Then came May 2023. Taco Bell asked the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to cancel the mark. Suddenly, two bright, bouncy words sounded like they might be headed for an expensive argument. There could have been filings, counterfilings, and months of corporate chest-thumping over who got to invite America to eat tacos on a Tuesday. Instead, Creel and Taco John’s chose a different ending. On July 18, 2023, the company announced it would give up the trademark rather than spend heavily on lawyers. Creel said Taco John’s was still proud of being the home of Taco Tuesday, but paying millions to defend the phrase didn’t feel like the right thing to do. That was the turn in the story. Not a gavel. Not a victory lap. Just a company deciding the money could do something better than sit in the middle of a food fight. Taco John’s pledged $100 per restaurant, up to $40,000, to CORE — Children of Restaurant Employees. The nonprofit helps food-and-beverage workers with children when families face medical crises, disasters, or other hardships. In other words, cash that might have gone toward arguing about tacos could instead help restaurant families through the kind of week when Tuesday dinner is the least of anyone’s worries. The company also invited Taco Bell to make a matching per-restaurant donation. It was a neat little nudge across the aisle, or maybe across the drive-thru lane. If everybody was going to share the phrase, maybe everybody could share the kindness too. And just like that, the phrase loosened its tie. “Taco Tuesday” became free for church suppers, corner bars, rival taco shops, family kitchens, and anyone else with tortillas and a sense of Tuesday-night optimism. The words no longer had to belong to one chain’s paperwork. They could belong to the person shredding lettuce at home, the server carrying a wobbling tray of tacos, the kid asking for extra cheese with the seriousness of a tiny negotiator. Taco John’s didn’t stop being proud of where the phrase had lived. It simply stopped guarding the gate. What could have been a corporate tussle became something lighter: a decision to step aside, spend less on lawyers, and send help where it could matter. In the end, the Wyoming chain let everyone have seconds.

Restaurant workers prepare tacos and family meals beside blank envelopes in a modern Cheyenne dining room.

Listen to this story, narrated.

Keep reading

All stories